Not a Subscriber? Register Now
Juveniles with Mandatory Life Sentences Should be ResentencedOctober 19, 2012 by John Lash by John Lash
The recent decision (reported here by the L.A. Times) by the U.S. Supreme Court to ban mandatory juvenile life without parole has been rightly celebrated as a victory by activists and others interested in progressive policies. The ruling has left many scratching their heads in its wake though, mostly because the court ruled the sentences unconstitutional, but did not directly assign a process for revisiting the cases, many of which are decades old.
A few opponents to the ruling are even contending that it cannot be applied retroactively. Youth Radio interviewed Jennifer Bishop, the President of theNational Organization of Victims of Juvenile Lifers. Ms. Bishop, who has previously written for JJIE, is a victims’ rights advocate whose group focuses on those most affected by juvenile murderers: families. The group’s website, teenkillers.org, offers links to analyses of the court’s decision that argue for letting current sentences stand, a very narrow interpretation of the ruling.
In Michigan, second only to Pennsylvania in the number of affected prisoners, the court of Appeals is hearing a case that, “may shape the fate of 368 prisoners serving mandatory life sentences…” committed as juveniles. Jonathan Oosting, writing for MLive, details the difficulties facing the court. These same difficulties will be faced in jurisdictions around the country. Some states will use legislation to move into compliance, as Reutersexplained in a September article on California’s new law covering relevant cases.
Others, at least for a time, will depend on courts to solve the problem. This will have its own difficulties, since in many ways this is asking the court to create law. The presiding appeals court judge in Michigan, Michael J. Talbot, points out that it is unclear whether or not the Supreme Court’s decision was substantive or, “merely a procedural issue.” If it is substantive, it affects all cases. If not, then the ruling would only apply to the cases before the court and to future cases. Talbot, speaking about the decision, said, “If Kagan had the votes, she would have said it was substantive. But it's not clear because she didn't."
This confusion is unfortunate, and it means that advocates, both for and against the ruling have a lot of work left to do. It is likely that these cases will drag on for years. For me the decision is easy. I favor resentencing of all affected prisoners. I realize that this will put a burden on the courts and everyone else involved, most unfortunately of all on the victims.
I see no other way forward though. The trend in the court’s recent decisions is clear, and argues for taking into account the differences between juveniles and adults. This way of viewing young people will likely continue, and it is in fact supported by science and research. Let’s take the time, and the trouble, to look at these cases now. The states will still be allowed to implement life without parole if they deem it necessary, but those serving the sentences, most of whom are adults now, deserve the chance to have their cases looked at through this evolving lens of understanding into how the adolescent mind works, and how it can change.
You must Login before leaving a comment.
JJ Today Notes
John Lash | 03/07/14We Can’t Improve the US by Fishing for Red Herring... More
John Lash | 03/03/14‘The War on Drugs’ Makes Kids Less Safe... More
John Lash | 02/21/14OP-ED: Restorative Justice Isn’t a Plug and Play O... More
Jim Hundrieser | 02/20/14LGBT Students Deserve Quality – and Equality – On ... More
Jean Rhodes | 02/17/14OP-ED: Social Media and the New Landscape of Youth... More
John Lash | 02/14/14OP-ED: One Boy’s Story of Solitary Confinement... More
Ellen Kahn | 02/12/14In Two North Carolina Stories of LGBTQ Youth, Trag... More
Latest Tweets From Youth Today
We Can’t Improve the US by Fishing for Red Herrings
Written by John Lash | 03/07/2014
It is a fact that it is not easy being black or Latino in the United States. More specifically, it’s not safe, particularly for boys and young men. As a nation we seem reluctant to fully confront this reality, or to address its causes and long history. In some quarters there is also an obstinate unwillingness to acknowledge anything beyond personal responsibility or to extend assistance to people based on social and historical realities.
In this world view those having a tough time — the poor, minorities, the...
American Camp Association Urges National System for Employee Background Checks
Stell Simonton | 03/06/2014 | Full Article
Innovative Ways to Engage Kids Displayed at National AfterSchool Association Conference
Roxanna Asgarian | 03/04/2014 | Full Article
Award Ceremony Honors New York After-School Educators, Programs
Roxanna Asgarian | 03/04/2014 | Full Article