Not a Subscriber? Register Now
Have We Gotten It Wrong on School ReformDecember 07, 2011 by Samantha Stone
Center on Education Policy
A letter from Jack Jennings, CEO of the Center on Education Policy, analyzes a recent book by Marc S. Tucker titled Surpassing Shanghai: An Agenda for American Education Built on the World’s Leading Systems. Tucker points out in his book that education reform has began to follow the business practice of benchmarking; 45 states and the District of Columbia have adopted new common state standards for reading and mathematics that were developed based on the standards of other countries with the highest degrees of achievement.
In his book, Tucker analyzes Shanghai, Finland, Japan, Singapore and Ontario, countries and provinces that typically outperform Americans academically and identifies six factors that contribute to their success.
The regions fund schools equitably, which additional resources for those serving needy students, pay teachers competitively and comparably, invest in high-quality preparation, mentoring and professional development for teachers and leaders at government expense, provide time in the school schedule for collaborative planning and ongoing professional learning to continually improve instruction, organize a curriculum around problem-solving and critical thinking skills, and lastly, test students rarely but carefully using measures that require analysis, communication and defense of ideas.
Jennings argues that the United States is now beginning to implement some standards of other countries but are just beginning to do so and that it is too early to see the effects. Jennings adds that “most other practices of high-achieving countries are not being implemented broadly and consistently in the U.S.”
For example, teacher preparation programs vary widely in quality and many of the professional development efforts are short-term, disconnected or irrelevant, Jennings said.
Jennings closes his argument saying that not everything happening overseas is necessarily beneficial and applicable to the U.S. and that it is currently a good time to evaluate which reforms are working and make changes if need be.
To view a free version of this letter, please click here.
You must Login before leaving a comment.
Report Roundup Articles
Nickolas Bagley | 04/15/142014 Brown Center Report on American Education: Ho... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 04/05/14Race for Results: Building a Path to Opportunity f... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 03/30/14Prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder Among Child... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 03/16/14The Plummeting Labor Market Fortunes of Teens and ... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 03/13/14Prevalence of Childhood and Adult Obesity in the U... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 03/09/14After the Recall: Dangerous Products Remain in Hom... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 03/07/14Beyond Bullying: How Hostile School Climate Perpet... Read More
Nickolas Bagley | 02/27/14Taking a Deeper Dive into Afterschool: Positive Ou... Read More
Latest Tweets From Youth Today
Supporting Youth Driven Organizations Does Make a Difference
Written by Nancy Carter | 04/16/2014
Supporting youth voices was not as popular in the 1990s as it is today. Systems were afraid of what young adults had to say. The general public and many professionals felt teenagers and emerging adults, were “difficult” to work with, had “attitudes”, and that it was “too late to make a difference” in their lives. Small pockets of advocates around the country started to change that perspective and North Carolina joined the movement. I was fortunate to help develop a youth driven group called...